Learn About American Home Shield Home Warranties

Understanding American Home Shield Home Warranties

American Home Shield is a home warranty company that operates across the United States, providing service contracts that cover the repair or replacement of major home systems and appliances. A home warranty is different from homeowners insurance—while insurance covers damage from accidents or disasters, a warranty covers breakdowns of systems and appliances due to normal wear and tear. American Home Shield has been in business since 1971 and serves customers in most states, though coverage varies by location.

Free Guide to Removing Apps From Your Roku Device →

Home warranties work on a membership model. Homeowners pay an annual or monthly membership fee, and in return, the company covers repair or replacement costs for systems and appliances listed in their plan when they malfunction. When something breaks down, the homeowner contacts American Home Shield, pays a service call fee (typically between $75 and $150), and the company dispatches a technician from their network to fix or replace the item. The warranty company then covers the remaining cost, up to the limits specified in the plan.

The company offers different levels of coverage plans, from basic options that cover essential systems like plumbing and electrical to more comprehensive plans that include air conditioning, heating, water heaters, and kitchen appliances. Each plan has a service call fee that the homeowner pays each time a technician is needed, plus annual or monthly premiums that vary based on the plan selected and the homeowner's location.

American Home Shield operates in nearly all U.S. states, with the exception of a few territories. Their service area includes major metropolitan regions and rural areas, though some specific coverage options may not be available in all locations. The company uses a network of independent contractors and service professionals to perform repairs, meaning a homeowner's experience may vary depending on which technician is dispatched and their local availability.

Practical Takeaway: Before considering any home warranty, homeowners should understand that a warranty covers breakdowns due to normal use, not damage from neglect or lack of maintenance. It is useful to review what systems and appliances your home has and whether they are aging or likely to need repairs soon.

What Coverage Plans Include and Exclude

American Home Shield offers several different plan tiers, each with different inclusions. A basic plan typically covers essential home systems like plumbing, electrical, heating, and cooling. Mid-tier plans often add water heaters, well pumps, and septic systems. Higher-level plans may include kitchen appliances such as refrigerators, ovens, dishwashers, and washers and dryers, as well as other items like pool equipment or garage door openers.

Free Guide to Current Earring Style Trends →

It is important to understand what is NOT covered under a home warranty, as these exclusions are significant. American Home Shield, like most warranty companies, does not cover items that are not maintained properly. For example, if a heating system fails because the homeowner never had it serviced, the warranty may deny the claim. Pre-existing conditions—problems that existed before the warranty was purchased—are typically not covered. Damage from natural disasters, neglect, improper installation, or lack of maintenance will not be covered. Additionally, cosmetic damage or wear and tear that does not affect function is excluded.

The company also does not cover certain high-risk items that are expensive to replace. These commonly include swimming pools, spas, attached hot tubs, and roofing systems. Some plans exclude specific appliances or systems depending on their age or condition. For instance, if a refrigerator is more than 20 years old, it may not be covered under some plans. The warranty also typically does not cover items that require permits or professional licensing beyond the scope of a standard repair, such as major electrical panel work or structural repairs.

It is also worth noting that American Home Shield has coverage limits—meaning they will pay up to a certain amount per service call or per year for specific items. If a repair costs more than the limit, the homeowner pays the difference. Some items have lower limits than others. For example, a refrigerator repair might have a different coverage limit than an air conditioning system repair.

Practical Takeaway: When reviewing a plan, make a list of the appliances and systems in your home, note their age, and check whether they are covered and what the coverage limits are. Read the exclusions section carefully—what is not covered often matters more than what is.

Service Call Process and What to Expect

When a homeowner experiences a breakdown, the process to get service begins with contacting American Home Shield. The company accepts requests through their website, mobile app, or phone line. The homeowner needs to describe the problem and may be asked some basic questions to confirm that the item is covered under their plan and to diagnose the issue. Response times vary, but the company aims to schedule service within 24 to 48 hours in many areas, though this is not guaranteed and may be longer in rural or remote locations.

Learn How to Make Pastina at Home →

Once a service appointment is scheduled, a technician from American Home Shield's network will visit the home. These technicians are independent contractors rather than company employees, so their experience level and professionalism can vary. At the appointment, the homeowner is required to pay the service call fee upfront—this is usually between $75 and $150 but varies by location and plan type. The technician will then diagnose the problem and either repair the item or, if repair is not possible, issue approval for replacement.

If the technician determines that the item can be repaired, American Home Shield covers the parts and labor costs up to the limit specified in the plan. If the item cannot be repaired, the company may approve replacement with a similar model. However, the homeowner does not receive a new or upgraded version—the replacement will be a standard, functional model. The homeowner is not involved in selecting the replacement contractor; American Home Shield chooses who will perform the replacement and arranges it.

A common frustration for warranty holders is that they have limited control over the repair process. The homeowner cannot choose their own contractor—they must use someone from the company's network. Additionally, the company may choose a less expensive repair option over what the homeowner might prefer. If the repair cost exceeds the coverage limit, the homeowner pays the difference. Some homeowners report wait times of several weeks for replacement authorization or service appointments in certain areas, particularly during peak seasons like summer when air conditioning failures are common.

Practical Takeaway: Keep records of your service call fee receipts and any authorization numbers provided by American Home Shield. If a repair is denied, request written explanation of why it was denied so you can understand whether it was excluded from your plan or if there was another reason.

Cost Structure and Pricing Models

American Home Shield pricing varies significantly based on several factors: the plan selected, the location of the home, the age and condition of systems and appliances at the time of enrollment, and whether the home is in an urban or rural area. According to industry data from 2023, basic home warranty plans in the U.S. average between $300 and $600 per year, while more comprehensive plans can range from $600 to $1,200 or more annually. American Home Shield's pricing generally falls within this range, though specific costs for individual homes require a quote.

Free Guide To Finding New Grandparent Gifts →

The company typically offers monthly payment options as an alternative to annual lump-sum payments. Monthly premiums may be slightly higher when spread across the year compared to paying annually upfront. For example, a plan that costs $600 per year might cost $55 per month, which totals $660 annually. Service call fees are separate from the monthly or annual premium and are due each time a technician is dispatched, regardless of whether the item is under warranty or not.

Some homes may be declined coverage or offered coverage at a higher cost if the home's systems are particularly old or in poor condition. American Home Shield reserves the right to require a home inspection before issuing a quote, and they may exclude certain items from coverage based on their age or condition. For example, if a water heater is already 15 years old and near the end of its typical lifespan, it might be excluded from the plan or covered at a higher premium.

It is useful to compare the cost of the warranty against the likelihood of needing repairs. If a home's major systems and appliances are relatively new (under 5-7 years old), the cost of a warranty may not be worth it, since the probability of breakdown is lower. Conversely, if a home has aging systems and appliances, particularly if they are over 10 years old, a warranty may provide financial protection that outweighs the annual cost. On average, homeowners spend between $200 and $500 per year on home repairs and maintenance, so a warranty that costs